Site Map 
compiled by Christopher Chantrill Follow @chrischantrill on Twitter

 

        Contact

a usgovernmentspending.com briefing:

smaller text  bigger text    print view

US Welfare Spending History from 1900



In 1902 governments in the United States spent very little on relief of the poor, including less than 0.2 percent of GDP on relief and 0.25 percent of GDP on health care services. In the early 21st century, governments spend over 8 percent of GDP on welfare programs, including health care for the poor.

A Century of Welfare Spending

Welfare spending began its ascent during the Great Depression.

Chart 2.61: Welfare Spending in 20th Century

Welfare spending, on programs for relief, unemployment compensation, and income support, started out at the beginning of the 20th century at 0.1 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). It was not until the crisis of the Great Depression that welfare expenditures began their secular rise, reaching 2.1 percent of GDP by 1940.

During World War II, welfare expenditures declined to about one percent of GDP per year, and fluctuated between one and two percent per year, depending on the business cycle. Health care expenditure amounted to about one percent of GDP. By the early 1960s, welfare cost about two percent of GDP.

The Great Society programs started welfare on an upward path, so that after 1980 welfare spending fluctuated between 3 and 4 percent of GDP, spiking during recessions.

In 1996 President Clinton signed a reform of welfare, and welfare costs declined from 3.4 percent of GDP during the 1990-91 recession to a low of 2.4 percent of GDP in 2000.

In the 2001-02 recession welfare costs increased to 3.1 percent of GDP in 2003 and then declined to 2.5 percent of GDP by 2007. But the Great Recession of 2009-10 produced an explosion in welfare costs to a peak of 4.75 percent of GDP in 2010. Welfare costs are expected to decline to 2.88 percent of GDP by 2015.


Governments Sharing the Cost of the Poor

When government spending on welfare began to expand in the Great Depression, it was mainly a state and local affair. But in the 1960s the federal government got into welfare in a big way.

Chart 2.62: Welfare Cost by Government Share

Prior to the Great Depression, non-health care expenditures on the poor were minimal, less than 0.2 percent of GDP. But in the Great Depression state and local governments sharply increased spending on welfare, with an initial boost from the federal government, and expenditures reached 2 percent of GDP in 1940. Between 1940 and 1960 welfare was mainly borne by state governments, with total cost fluctuating between 1 and 2 percent of GDP including a 0.5 percent contribution from the federal government.

Chart Key:
- Local direct spending
- State direct spending
- Federal direct spending
- Transfer to state and local

In the 1960s the federal government started to dominate welfare spending, contributing about half of the 4 percent of GDP cost by the early 1980s and about two-thirds of the 5 percent of GDP cost in the Great Recession in 2010.

Relief Payments, Housing, and Unemployment

There are three major welfare programs: relief (or income security), housing rent subsidies, and unemployment benefits.

Chart 2.63: The Three Major Welfare Programs

Prior to the Great Depression, the only welfare program was direct relief, then called “public welfare” or “public assistance.” It cost about 0.1 to 0.15 percent of GDP. Then relief payments surged to 0.75 percent in 1932, 1.25 percent in 1933, peaking at nearly 1.5 percent of GDP in 1934.

Chart Key:
- Unemployment
- Housing
- Relief (income security)

In the mid 1930s welfare became differentiated into public assistance, housing subsidy, and unemployment benefits. Housing and unemployment are treated below. Public assistance payments peaked at 1.4 percent of GDP in the 1938 recession.

Welfare benefits declined in World War II, with income security at 0.51 percent GDP in 1944.

After World War II relief payments steadied at a little below 1 percent of GDP. In the mid 1960s came the War on Poverty. Public assistance payments doubled to 1.8 percent GDP by the mid 1970s, h

In 1991 after the 1990 recession, income security benefits peaked at 1.97 percent of GDP, after 15 years ranging between 1.6 and 1.8 percent of GDP. But then they began to decline throughout the 1990s, and President Clinton signed a reform of welfare in 1996. Income security benefits hit a low of 1.24 percent GDP in 2001.

In the 2000s income security benefits stayed below 1.4 percent of GDP, but in the Great Recession they cranked up to 1.91 percent of GDP. Income security benefits, including SNAP, EITC, SSI, and TANF, are expected to decline to 1.6 percent of GDP by 2015.

Housing Subsidies

Housing subsidies have steadily increased over the years.

Chart 2.64: Subsidies for Housing

Prior to the Great Depression, the only welfare program was direct relief, but a program of housing allowances emerged as part of the New Deal ethos.

In the mid 1930s housing spending quickly increased from zero to 0.1 percent of GDP in 1937 before peaking at 0.37 percent of GDP in 1942. After World War II housing spending declined down to about 0.1 percent GDP.

Starting at 0.09 percent of GDP in 1948 housing spending expanded briskly over the next three decades, hitting 0.2 percent GDP in 1951, 0.3 percent GDP in 1972, 0.4 percent GDP in 1980. Housing spending spiked to 0.82 percent of GDP in 1985 with a special payment for low-income housing loan programs.

Since the spike in the mid 1980s, housing spending has settled down in the range 0.5 to 0.55 percent of GDP. Housing spending peaked at 0.69 percent of GDP in the recession year of 2010, and is expected to decline to 0.48 percent of GDP in 2015.

Unemployment Benefits

Unemployment benefits peak during recessions, but have a base of about 0.5 percent GDP at the peak of the business cycle.

Chart 2.65: Unemployment Benefits

In the aftermath of the Great Depression governments all worked to create government-based unemployment systems to pay benefits to laid-off workers from taxes laid on employers.

In the mid 1930s governments started making unemployment benefit payments to unemployed workers, increasing from zero to 0.49 percent of GDP by 1940. During World War II unemployment benefit payments decreased to 0.03 percent of GDP in 1944.

In the 1950s unemployment benefits hit about 0.7 percent GDP during recessions and declined to about 0.3 percent GDP during good times. Unemployment spending peaked at just over 1 percent of GDP in 1962 and then declined to about 0.4 percent during the mid-1960s boom.

Unemployment benefits spiked to 0.87 percent of GDP in 1971 after the mild recession of 1969-70, and to 1.9 percent of GDP in 1976 after the much more severe recession of 1974-75.

In the 1980s and thereafter, unemployment spending declined to about 0.5 percent of GDP at the peak of an economic boom and spiked upwards after each recession. On that record the most severe recession has been the Great Recession of 2008-09. Unemployment benefit payments peaked at 2.06 percent of GDP in 2010. Unemployment benefit spending is expected to decrease to 0.7 percent of GDP in 2015.

Government Healthcare Spending on the Poor

Governments spent up to one percent of GDP on health care for the poor until the 1960s. Now the total is reaching 4 percent of GDP. (This excludes Medicare, the federal health program for senior citizens.)

Chart 2.66: Medicaid and Government Health Care

Health care expenditures by governments, mainly state and local, began the 20th century at about 0.25 percent of GDP. By 1960, after a temporary decline in World War II, expenditures had reached about one percent of GDP.

The joint federal-state Medicaid program to deliver health care for the poor began in the 1960s and reached 1 percent GDP in 1991. In the 1990s Medicaid increased rapidly, doubling to 2 percent of GDP in 2002. Thereafter it increased steadily, year after year, and is expected to reach 3 percent of GDP by 2015.

Other health care expenditures (mainly state and local) reached 1.25 percent of GDP in the early 1980s and have remained at that level ever since.

Spending 101 Courses

Spending | Federal Debt | Revenue | Defense | Welfare | Healthcare | Education
Debt History | Entitlements | Deficits | State Spending | State Taxes | State Debt


There’s More...

usgovernmentspending.com.

Where you go to get facts about government.

Prepared by Christopher Chantrill.
email: chrischantrill@gmail.com

Click the image on the right to buy usgovernmentspending.com’s ebook.
It costs only $0.99 and it contains all the analyses of spending history
on the website and more.

Top Spending Requests:

Find DEFICIT stats and history.

Get WELFARE stats and history.

US BUDGET overview and pie chart.

Find NATIONAL DEBT today.

See FEDERAL BUDGET breakdown and estimated vs. actual.

MILITARY SPENDING details, budget and history.

ENTITLEMENT SPENDING history.

See BAR CHARTS of spending, debt.

See PIE CHARTS of total spending, federal spending.

Check STATE spending: CA NY TX FL and compare.

See SPENDING HISTORY briefing.

Take a COURSE at Spending 101.

Make your own CUSTOM CHART.

Spending Data Sources

Spending data is from official government sources.
  Federal data since 1962 comes from the president’s budget.
  All other spending data comes from the US Census Bureau.

Gross Domestic Product data comes from US Bureau of Economic Analysis and measuringworth.com.

Detailed table of spending data sources here.

Federal spending data begins in 1792.

State and local spending data begins in 1890.

State and local spending data for individual states begins in 1957.

Site Search

Win Cash for Bugs

File a valid bug report and get a $5 Amazon Gift Certificate.

Next Data Update

> State Quarterly Taxes FY14

> data update schedule.

Data Source

Source: CBO Long-Term Budget Outlook .

> data sources for other years
> data update schedule.

Medicare/Social Security Trustee Reports Released

On July 28, 2014, the Center for Medicare Services released its annual Medicare Trustees Report, which projects Medicare spending out into the 2080s.  As in the past, the report shows that federal health-care programs will eat the budget.

UsGovernmentspending.com has updated its chart of the Medicare Outlook here based on data in the 2014 Medicare Trustees Report.  You can download the data and also view selected Medicare Trustee forecasts going back to 2005.

On July 28, 2014, the Social Security Administration released its annual OASDI Trustees Report, which projects Social Security spending out into the 2080s.  As in the past, the report shows that Social Security spending will max out at about 6 percent of GDP.

UsGovernmentspending.com is publishing for the first time a chart of the Social Security Outlook here based on data in the 2014 OASDI Trustees Report.  You can download the data and also view OASDI Trustee forecasts for 2005 and 1997.

Spend links

us numbersus budgetcustom chartdeficit/gdpspend/gdpdebt/gdpus gdpus real gdpstate gdpbreakdownfederalstatelocal200920102011californiatexas

Masthead

usgovernmentspending.com was designed and executed by:

Christopher Chantrill.

Email here.


presented by Christopher Chantrill
Data Sources  •  Contact